2012 Award Winners
| Award | Actor | Production |
|---|---|---|
| Best Cameo Performance | Milan Trotman | Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat |
| Best Cabaret Performance | Charlotte Morris | |
| Best Character Development | Matt O'Connor | Dodger |
| Best Comedic Performance | Alex Giganti | Dodger |
| Best Comedy Improv Performance | Jacob Bowman | |
| Best Emerging Youth | Isabella Salvi | |
| Best Emerging Teen | Kayla Warren | |
| The Hitchcock Award for Youth Leadership | Julia Meckley | |
| Rising Star Award | Sebi Santiago-Rivas | |
| Best Supporting Performance in a Play | Sarah Schieffelin | The Trojan Women |
| Best Leading Performance in a Play | Addie Weyrich | The Trojan Women |
| Best Supporting Performance in a Musical | Julia Hopkins | Dodger |
| Best Leading Performance in a Musical | Meredith Brandt Daniel Wisniewski | Dodger Dodger |
| Lifetime Achievement | Allison Boyle Jake Westphal | |
| Best Ensemble | Dodger |