2005 Award Winners
| Award | Actor | Production |
|---|---|---|
| Best Cameo | Samantha Evans | Via Dolorosa |
| Best Character Development | Alyssa Depte | Via Dolorosa |
| Best Comedic Performance | Jen D'Angelo | This Side Up |
| Best Comedy Improv Performance | Dana Kaplan-Angle | |
| Best Emerging Performer Youth | Jake Westphal | |
| Best Emerging Performer Teen | Rebecca Bokeko | |
| Best Supporting Performance (Play) | Rebecca Sherman | Via Dolorosa |
| Best Performance in a Play | Lexie Braverman Shane Gillern | Via Dolorosa Via Dolorosa |
| Best Supporting Performance (Musical or Film) | Anna Flynn-Meketon | Aida |
| Best Performance in a Musical or Film | Sarah Steele Annie Westphal | Broadway Belles in Concert Broadway Belles in Concert |
| Lifetime Achievement | Shana Knizhnik | |
| Best Ensemble | Broadway Belles in Concert |